Introduction
When it comes to protecting your home, your roof plays a crucial role in safeguarding against harsh weather conditions and maintaining energy efficiency. If you’re considering a complete roof replacement, understanding asphalt roofing and its benefits is essential. Asphalt shingles are one of the most popular roofing materials due to their affordability, durability, and versatility. However, over time, exposure to the elements can cause wear and tear, leading to the need for a replacement.
For the homeowner that needs a roofing service in York, PA, identifying the signs of roof damage before they get too costly is crucial. When your roof is damaged by a storm or its age is showing, being aware of local roofing services nearest to you can offer quick and effective repairs.
Following are the steps to replace an asphalt roof, from evaluating what you currently have to choosing the best material and contractor, and so on.
Asphalt Roof vs. Other Roofing Options
When it’s time to replace your roof, compare asphalt shingles to other popular types of roofing material to see which best fits your house. Asphalt shingles are still the most popular choice because they’re cheap and easy to install, but other types of material might have longer lifespans and more durability.
Asphalt Shingles (Most Common Choice)
Pros:
- Affordable: One of the cheaper types of roofing material out there.
- Easy to Install & Replace: Easy installation and easy repair make it DIY-friendly.
- Variety of Styles & Colors: Available in different colors and textures to fit any home decor.
- Reasonable Lifespan: Can have a lifespan of 20-30 years if maintained regularly.
- Energy-Efficient Models: New shingles are available with reflective coatings for added energy efficiency.
Cons:
- Susceptible to Extreme Weather: Susceptible to Severe Weather: Damaged by heavy rain, high winds, and hail.
- Shorter Lifespan than Other Materials: Shorter lifespan compared to metal or tile roofing.
- Can Be Prone to Algae & Moss Growth: Requires maintenance in wet conditions.
Best for: Budget-minded homeowners looking for affordable, stylish, and low-maintenance roofs.
Metal Roofing (Durable & Long-Lasting)
Pros:
- Extremely Durable: Could last 40-70 years, longer than asphalt shingles.
- Weather-Resistant: Possesses high wind resistance, heavy rain resistance, and fire resistance.
- Energy-Efficient: Reflects back sunlight, saving cooling expenses in hot climates.
- Low Maintenance: Does not require constant treatment or repair.
Cons:
- Higher Upfront Cost: More expensive than asphalt shingles.
- Noisy in Rain or Hail: Can be loud without proper insulation.
- Potential for Denting: Softness of aluminum allows denting by hail or trash.
Best for: Homeowners who desire long-term longevity, energy efficiency, and low maintenance.
Tile Roofing (Stylish & Long-Lasting)
Pros:
- Aesthetic Appeal: Available in clay, concrete, and slate, which provides homes with a sophisticated appearance.
- Extremely Long Lifespan: Will endure for 50+ years if properly maintained.
- Fire-Resistant & Weather-Resistant: Best suited for dry, hot climates.
Cons:
- Very Expensive: More expensive initial cost compared to metal or asphalt.
- Heavy Weight: Heavy enough that roofing must be designed to bear it.
- Fragile to Impact: Stepping on or falling branches can shatter tiles.
Best for: Homeowners who want luxurious, long-lasting, and fireproof roofing.
Wood Shingles/Shakes (Natural & Classic Look)
Pros:
- Rustic & Natural Appearance: Ideal for old, vintage, or antique houses.
- Good Insulation Properties: Maintains indoor temperatures.
Cons:
- High Maintenance: Water damaged and needs to be sealed and treated every now and then.
- Fire Hazard: In some areas, application is banned because of fire hazards.
- Costly: Pricier compared to asphalt shingles.
Best for: Homeowners who desire a distinctive, natural, and traditional look with regular upkeep.
Weather Impact on Asphalt Roofs
Different climates handle asphalt shingles differently:
- Hot Climates: Shingles can warp or crack from excess heat.
- Cold Climates: Freeze-thaw cycles cause shingle brittleness and cracking.
- Storm-Prone Areas: Excessive rain and windy conditions loosen shingles and cause leaks.
- Snow & Ice Regions: Ice dams can be created by them, potentially causing water damage.
Property owners must select weather-resistant shingles and utilize proper ventilation in an attempt to prolong their roof’s life expectancy.
Understanding Roofing Estimates & Contracts
When investing in a complete roof replacement, keep an eye on your roofing estimate. A professional estimate should have:
- Material cost (shingles, underlayment, flashing, etc.)
- Labor cost
- Removal and disposal of old roof material
- Permits and inspections
- Warranties information
To shield yourself from scams, always:
- Get more than one quote from licensed contractors.
- Check references and online reviews.
- Ensure the company is insured and licensed.
Tear-Off vs. Overlay: Which Is Best?
There are two ways of replacing an asphalt roof:
Tear-Off Replacement (Preferred)
- Removes old shingles completely before new installation.
- Provides a solid foundation and long-term performance.
- More costly but better long-term value.
Overlay (Roof-Over)
- Place new shingles on top of old ones.
- Less costly but could create underlying structural issues.
- Could reduce the lifespan of new shingles.
Full tear-off usually is the best solution for long-term performance.
Roofing and Energy Efficiency Innovations
New roofing technology helps make houses energy efficient:
- Cool Roof Shingles – Reflect more sunlight, less heat absorbed.
- Solar Reflective Coatings – Save on cooling costs by cooling roofs.
- Proper Ventilation – Repels attic heat, reducing HVAC burden.
If you care about energy efficiency, choose ENERGY STAR®-qualified asphalt shingles.
Sustainability & Recycling Asphalt Shingles
Did you know asphalt shingles can be recycled?
- Used-up shingles can be recycled as road pavement.
- There are even some companies that provide environmental-friendly shingle options.
- Recycling saves landfill waste and is good for the environment.
If sustainability is a concern for you, inquire with your roofing contractor about shingle recycling programs.
Common Myths About Asphalt Roof Replacement
Myth 1: “I can replace my roof any time of year.”
- Although roofing is possible year-round, spring and fall are the ideal times.
Myth 2: “A new roof doesn’t boost home value.”
- An excellent roof enhances curb appeal and resale value.
Myth 3: “Roof replacements take weeks to complete.”
- Even most asphalt roof replacements take only 1-3 days, depending on the size.
Myth 4: “All asphalt shingles are the same.”
- Quality does make a difference! Choose high-performance, weather-resistant shingles for a long lifetime.
In Conclusion
Replacing your asphalt roof is a big investment, but choosing the proper materials and a reliable contractor can offer long-term security to your residence. If you need a complete roof replacement or emergency roofing repairs, contact Yeager Home Improvement for quality roofing service in York, PA, to make it easy and convenient.
What to Do Next for Homeowners:
✔ Schedule a roof inspection if you suspect damage.
✔ Compare quotes from several licensed roofing contractors and compare.
✔ Select the highest-quality asphalt shingles for your local climate.
✔ Review warranty and maintenance provisions to ensure long-term reliability.
With proper planning, your new roof will bring years of safety and peace of mind!
